A fraternity of revolutionary officersâor a monarchist conspiracy?
In May 1782, seven months after the British armyâs surrender at Yorktown, Va., General George Washington was at his headquarters in a fieldstone farmhouse near Newburgh, N.Y. Peace talks were beginning in Paris, and thousands of soldiers encamped at Newburgh were awaiting the orders that would disband the Continental Army. Many of them had joined short-lived mutinies during the war, raging at Congress for failing to clothe and feed them. Now, as the warâs end seemed near, Congress again was not giving the troops back pay or promised pensions. The soldiers were angry, as were their officers.
One of them, Colonel Lewis Nicola, wrote a long letter to Washington in response to âseveral conversations I have had with officers, & some I have overheard among soldiers.â The rambling letter finally came to the point: âThis war must have shown to all, but to military men in particular, the weakness of republicks [sic].â¦I believe strong argument might be produced for admitting the title of king, which I conceive would be attended with some material advantages.â
Nicola shared another idea: Congress should procure âa sufficient tract in some of the best of those fruitful & extensive countries to the west of our frontiers.â These lands could be âformed into a distinct State under such mode of government as those military who choose to remove to it may agree on.â Presumably, the mode would be a monarchy.
Washingtonâs reaction was immediate: âBe assured, Sir, no occurrence in the course of the War has given me more painful sensations than your information of there being such ideas existing in the Army. â¦Banish these thoughts from your Mind and never communicate, as from yourself or any one else, a sentiment of the like Nature.â
The chastised Nicola seems to have obeyed Washington. But the mutterings about monarchy continued. Little more than a month after getting the letter from Nicola, Washington received one from Maj. Gen. James Mitchell Varnum of the Rhode Island militia. Because âAvarice, Jealously & Luxuryâ control the people of the failing republic, Varnum argued, âabsolute Monarchy, or a military State, can alone rescue them.â In responding to Varnum, Washington did not express outrage. Wearily he conceded that âdestructive passionsâ¦too generally pervade all Ranks,â and he hoped those in time âshall give place to that love of Freedom which first animated us in this Contest.â
Frustrated, fuming and uncertain about their postwar world, officers like Nicola and Varnum would be among the founding members of Americaâs first veteransâ organization, the Society of the Cincinnati. How the society was formed, how its members flirted with monarchy and how some of them got possession of large swaths of that western land is a story that tracks through the crucial time between the end of the Revolutionary War and the creation of a new nation. The Society of the Cincinnati was born at Newburgh, and its members fanned out from there to enter historyâdrafting the Constitution, openly or covertly engaging in postwar politics, and bestowing upon America its first conspiracy theory.
At Newburgh the months dragged by, as they did in New York City, where the British army also awaited news of peace. More and more men of the Continental Army were drifting away from Newburgh. Washington realized that if his Army dissolved, the British would react with an attack, and the war would suddenly resume. In October 1782 he wrote to Secretary of War Benjamin Lincoln, who had served as a distinguished major general. âThe patience and long sufferance of this Army are almost exhausted,â Washington wrote. âThere never was so great a spirit of Discontent as at this instant.â
That month Washington ordered the Army to a set up a winter cantonment in a forested area at the edge of the Hudson Highlands, about five miles southwest of Newburgh. By then the Northern Department of the Continental Army numbered some 7,000 troops. Accompanying them were about 500 women and children. Although Washington wanted to take leave and spend time at Mount Vernon, he was concerned about the sullen mood of his troops and felt obliged, as he wrote wartime aide James McHenry, âto stick very close to my flock this winter & try like a careful physician to prevent, if possible, the disorders getting to an incurable height.â
To keep his grumbling troops busy, Washington put them to work chopping down trees and building nearly 600 log huts of uniform size and shape, neatly arrayed regiment by regiment. At the suggestion of a chaplain, the soldiers also erected the centerpiece of the cantonment, a 110-by-30-foot log building with a vaulted ceiling, windows and plaster walls. It was dubbed the Temple of Virtue.
In December 1782 several officers, including some facing debtorsâ prison, sent a chilling warning to Congress: âAny further experiments on their patience may have fatal effects.â Then, in March 1783, Washington received one of the copies of an anonymous letter circulating among the officers. The writer, calling himself a âfellow soldier,â asked whom peace would bless ââA country willing to redress your wrongs?…Or is it rather a country that tramples upon your rights, disdains your cries and insults your distresses?â The 1,200-word letter urged the officers to meet and âcome to some final opinionâ about what to do next.
The Newburgh lettersâNicolaâs, Varnumâs and now this oneâwere the first stirrings of what Thomas Jefferson later described as âa cabal of the officers of the Army who proposed to establish a monarchy and to propose it to General Washington.â
Washington responded to the anonymous letter by ordering the officers to postpone their meeting for a few days and assemble at the Temple of Virtue on March 15. He was enough of a scholar of the classics to realize this was the Ides of March, the day of Julius Caesarâs 44 BC assassination.
Surprising the officers, Washington himself strode into the temple and stood on its raised platform. He denounced the anonymous letter and asked the officers âto express your utmost horror and detestation of the Man whoâ¦ wickedly attempts to open the flood Gates of Civil discord and deluge our rising Empire in Blood.â
After he finished his speech, Washington started to read a letter from a congressman regarding strained finances. He faltered and then reached into a pocket for spectacles the officers had never seen him wear. âGentlemen,â he said, âyou will permit me to put on my spectacles, for I have not only grown gray but almost blind in the service of my country.â Many men began to weep. Washington finished reading the letter and walked out. The officers then adopted resolutions rejecting âthe infamous propositionsâ in the anonymous letter and reaffirming their confidence in Congress. It was a moment that endures into our time. The U.S. Armyâs Field Manual 1 cites Washingtonâs action at Newburgh, when âthe future of the Republic was in doubt,â as a lesson to instill in American soldiers the indisputable fact that the military is under civilian control.
The month after Washingtonâs speech, on the eighth anniversary of the battles of Lexington and Concord, an officer stood at the door of the temple and read a proclamation of Congress declaring a cessation of hostilities. The Revolutionary War was over, but a political war had already begun over whether the nation should have a strong central government or continue to give most power to the states. Also in dispute was the existence of a peacetime armyâa suspicious source of military power and an echo of the âstanding armiesâ listed as a grievance against King George III in the Declaration of Independence.
During the crisis at Newburgh, several members of Congress, led by former Lt. Col. Alexander Hamilton, believed the mere threat of a military coup dâÃ©tat would accelerate the creation of a strong central government. But Washington, seeing the perils of a political-military alliance, warned Hamilton, âThe Armyâ¦is a dangerous instrument to play with.â As Washington well knew, Maj. Gen. Horatio Gates, commander of the cantonment, had plotted with members of Congress in 1777 to replace Washington as head of the Continental Army. Gates still had congressional allies. And the anonymous letter eventually was traced to Major John Armstrong Jr., Gatesâ aide-de-camp.
West Point, the Army citadel 13 miles down the Hudson River from the tense Newburgh cantonment, was under the command of Maj. Gen. Henry Knox, a hero of the Revolution and a close comrade of Washington. Knox, wishing to preserve the officersâ wartime comradeship, decided to organize the Society of the Cincinnati. He also saw the society as an advocacy group and a source for officers in need. There was no thought of including enlisted men. The Continental Army, modeled on the British army, prohibited fraternization between officers and men.
Knox discussed the idea with other officers, including Maj. Gen. Baron Friedrich Wilhelm von Steuben of Prussia, who as drillmaster at Valley Forge, Pa., had transformed the Continental Army. The society formally convened at Steubenâs headquarters on May 13, 1783, and quickly added to its membership more than 2,000 officersâ among them Nicola, Varnum, Gates, Armstrong and Hamilton. Washington agreed to be the societyâs founding president general. The society extended membership to many French officers who had served in the war, including Maj. Gen. Gilbert du Motier, Lt. Gen. Jean-Baptiste Donatien de Vimeur, Lt. Gen. FranÃ§ois-Joseph Paul de Grasse and Major Pierre Charles LâEnfant.
LâEnfant, who would later survey and lay out the District of Columbia, designed the societyâs bald eagle insignia. He went to France, commissioned a jeweler to create the societyâs badge and asked King Louis XVI to approve the order, as the society was known in France. The king made himself patron of the order and the judge of whether a French officer could be admitted. He continued as patron until 1793, when revolutionaries convicted him of high treason and sent him to the guillotine. The order itself soon went dormant. In America the societyâs badge became a target of critics, who denounced the decoration as an aristocratic and monarchist symbol.
The society itself takes its name from citizen-soldier Lucius Quinctius Cincinnatus, whom the Roman Senate had summoned from forced retirement on his farm in 460 BC when enemy armies threatened Rome. Later made dictator by the Senate, Cincinnatus led his troops to a swift, victorious defense of the city. His duty done, he refused any rewards and returned to his farm.
When word of the society began to spread, rumors of a military conspiracy quickly arose, primarily because under society rules, at death, membership passed to the eldest male descendant. This inflamed suspicions the society had ânobleâ ambitions. A widely circulated pamphlet, reprinted in many newspapers, spread the alarm to every state. In a world ruled by kings and emperors, the vision of an American republic was novel and hard for many to see. Proponents of a republic perceived the society of military officers as a dangerous group, believing with Jefferson that Army officers were âtrained to monarchy by military habits.â
Knox personified the dilemma. The former Boston bookseller, in a letter to a fellow Cincinnatian, wrote, âI confess I hate the office of Kings.â But he added, âPerhaps of all kinds of monarchs an absolute one is bestâ¦[as] he feels no rising of the black passions produced by opposition to his Will.â In the same letter Knox expressed his belief that âa republican Government, formed upon national principles â¦propagated and perpetuated by habits, may exist a great length of time.â
Jefferson, railing against âthe establishment of an [sic] hereditary order,â saw Knox and Steuben as âthe leading agentsâ in a plot to make Washington a king. On his way to Philadelphia in May 1784 for the first general meeting of the society, Washington called on Jefferson and confided his fear of a monarchy. Washington agreed the hereditary rule had to be abolished. At the meeting, perhaps expecting a public critique, delegates agreed to keep the deliberations secret. But Massachusetts delegate Winthrop Sargent kept a journal and encrypted Washingtonâs words. When the delegateâs grandsonâa hereditary memberâcracked the code in the mid-19th century, the journal revealed that Washington had suggested the abolition of the society and had brought with him a letter from Gilbert du Motier urging the same.
Washingtonâs own written recollection of the meeting shows he was aware of rumors that the society was the hotbed of a potential military coup: âStrike out every word, sentence and clause which has a political tendency. Discontinue the hereditary part in all its connexions [sic], absolutely, without any substitution which can be construed into concealment.â The society later sent Washingtonâs proposed changes to its state chapters, several of which tabled or refused to ratify them. Upon Washingtonâs death in 1799, delegates met to select Hamilton as president general. They also reinstated the hereditary rule.
Jefferson was not the only political leader who distrusted the society. John Adams called its formation âthe first step taken to deface the beauty of our Temple of Libertyâ and âthe deepest Piece of Cunning yet attempted.â Benjamin Franklin, Samuel Adams and John Jay all denounced the society, each foreseeing an American nobility that could create an America ruled by a man on a throne.
Suspicions of an Army-society conspiracy continued to crop up as proponents of a republic sought ways to replace the Articles of Confederation, the wartime agreement that enabled the coalition of states to function without a central government. Visionaries like James Madison of Virginia conceived the architecture of such a republic. In December 1786 Madison wrote to Washington, inviting him to a meeting in Philadelphia in May 1787, at which Madison hoped to bring forth his plan. That meeting would evolve into the convention that produced the U.S. Constitution.
Washington, however, turned down Madisonâs invitation. Incredibly, by a coincidence that added to suspicions of a conspiracy, the society was to have its national meeting in the same place at the same time. And Washington, having already told the society he would not be able to attend, felt he could not go to Philadelphia for the meeting Madison was organizing. Washington even seems to have fibbed when he had his secretary write to Knox, saying he would not be able to attend the societyâs meeting because âhis Mother & only Sister lay dangerously ill.â (His mother lived until 1789, his sister until 1797.)
Finally, after uncharacteristic dithering, Washington did go to Philadelphia. He was made president of the convention and imposed secrecy over the proceedings. He watched over the creation of the Constitution and began his journey to the presidency of the United States.
The final version of the Constitution envisioned a strong central government and gave extraordinary power to the chief executiveââleaning too much towards Monarchy,â one delegate complained. But the majority believed such power would be safe in the hands of George Washington, the model for all presidents to come.
When inaugurated on April 30, 1789, Washington remained president general of the Society of the Cincinnati, and fears of a monarchy still haunted the republic. âYou are now a king, under a different name,â said former aide James McHenry, a founding member of the society and Washingtonâs future secretary of war.
Suspicions about the society persisted into John Adamsâ presidency. But the societyâs members clearly accepted the new republic. Many became politicians, and early foes of the society, such as Benjamin Franklin, accepted honorary memberships. Of the 40 signers of the Constitution, 23 were original or honorary members of the society. James Monroe, an early member, became president. Andrew Jackson and Zachary Taylor were among several other presidents made honorary members.
Washington never gave up his membership. And when he became president, he did not forget Nicolaâs idea about giving officers grants to âthose fruitful & extensive countries to the west of our frontiers.â Some society members, as shareholders in a company that began development of the Northwest Territory, campaigned to make Ohio a state. Early in Washingtonâs first term, Maj. Gen. Arthur St. Clair, a society member, became the first governor of the Northwest Territory. When he arrived at Fort Washington, he changed the name of the settlement to Cincinnati.
During the early 19th century state chapters began disbanding, but the society went on. Today it comprises more than 3,800 members, most descendants of the original officers. Since 1938 the headquarters of the society [www.societyofthe cincinnati.org] has been Anderson House in Washington, D.C., a magnificent late Renaissance Revival mansion. The house contains a small museum and an outstanding library devoted to the military and naval history of the 18th century.
One of the libraryâs recent acquisitions is a calf-bound Continental Army orderly book kept by a captain at Newburgh in 1783. Besides noting regimental orders and the âstipulated price for Taylors [sic], Shoemakers, Barbers & Wash Women,â the captain wrote down in his firm handwriting the words Washington spoke on that fateful day at the Temple of Virtue.
For further reading Thomas Allen [www .tballen.com] recommends âLewis Nicola, George Washington and American Military Discontent During the Revolutionary War,â by Robert F. Haggard, assistant editor of The Papers of George Washington; accessible online at the American Philosophical Society [www.amphilsoc.org/sites/default/ files/201.pdf]. Also see Washington: The Indispensable Man, by James T. Flexner.
Originally published in the January 2013 issue of Military History. To subscribe, click here.